top of page

Taxation of Charitable Trust

Analysis of Section 11


Section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is a crucial provision that governs the taxation of income earned by charitable or religious trusts and institutions in India. This provision exempts such income from income tax, provided certain conditions are satisfied. In this analysis, we will delve deeper into the provisions of Section 11, examine the various conditions that must be met to claim exemption, and discuss some of the issues and challenges that arise in the implementation of this provision.


1. Introduction to Section 11:

Section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 provides for the exemption of income of a trust or institution created for charitable or religious purposes. The section applies to any trust or institution that is created for charitable or religious purposes and is registered under the relevant provisions of the law. The section provides that any income derived from property held under trust or other legal obligation for charitable or religious purposes shall be exempt from income tax to the extent that such income is applied for such purposes in India. In other words, the income of the trust or institution shall be exempt from income tax to the extent that it is utilized for the purposes for which the trust or institution was created.


2. Conditions for claiming exemption under Section 11:

In order to claim exemption under Section 11, certain conditions must be satisfied. These conditions are:

i. The trust or institution must be created for charitable or religious purposes only: The first condition for claiming exemption under Section 11 is that the trust or institution must be created for charitable or religious purposes only. The term "charitable purpose" has been defined in Section 2(15) of the Income Tax Act, which includes relief of the poor, education, medical relief, and the advancement of any other object of general public utility. The term "religious purpose" has not been defined in the Act but is generally understood to mean any activity that is connected with the promotion of religion.

ii. The income of the trust or institution must be applied for charitable or religious purposes in India: The second condition for claiming exemption under Section 11 is that the income of the trust or institution must be applied for charitable or religious purposes in India. This means that the income must be utilized for the purposes for which the trust or institution was created and must be spent within the territorial limits of India. If any income is spent outside India or is not spent for the purposes for which the trust or institution was created, it shall not be exempt from income tax.

iii. The trust or institution must maintain proper accounts of its income and expenditure: The third condition for claiming exemption under Section 11 is that the trust or institution must maintain proper accounts of its income and expenditure. This is necessary to ensure that the income is applied only for the purposes for which the trust or institution was created. The accounts must be maintained in a prescribed manner and must be audited by a chartered accountant.

iv. The trust or institution must file its income tax return in a timely manner: The fourth condition for claiming exemption under Section 11 is that the trust or institution must file its income tax return in a timely manner. The return must be filed in the prescribed form and within the prescribed time limit. If the return is not filed within the prescribed time limit, the exemption under Section 11 may be denied.


3. Exclusions from exemption under Section 11:


While Section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 provides an exemption from income tax to charitable or religious trusts or institutions, there are certain exclusions from this exemption. In this section, we will discuss the exclusions from exemption under Section 11.

a- Income not applied for charitable or religious purposes: One of the primary conditions for claiming exemption under Section 11 is that the income of the trust or institution must be applied for charitable or religious purposes in India. If any part of the income is not applied for such purposes, then that part of the income will not be exempt from tax. For example, if a trust earns Rs. 10 lakh as income, but spends only Rs. 8 lakh for charitable or religious purposes, then the remaining Rs. 2 lakh will not be exempt from tax.

b- Business income: If a trust or institution carries on any business activity, then the income from such activity will not be exempt under Section 11. The income from the business activity is taxable under the normal provisions of the Income Tax Act. However, if the business activity is incidental to the main object of the trust or institution, and the income from such activity is used for charitable or religious purposes, then such income may still be eligible for exemption under Section 11.

c- Income from property held for profit: If a trust or institution holds any property as an investment, and earns income from such property, then that income will not be exempt under Section 11. For example, if a trust owns a building and earns rent from it, then the rental income will not be exempt under Section 11. However, if the property is held as stock-in-trade, and is sold for a profit, then the income may be eligible for exemption under Section 11, provided that the income is used for charitable or religious purposes.

d- Anonymous donations: If a trust or institution receives any anonymous donation, and the value of such donation exceeds Rs. 10,000, then the donation will not be eligible for exemption under Section 11. The trust or institution must maintain a record of such donations, and if the identity of the donor is not known, then the donation will be taxed at the maximum marginal rate.

e- Specific donations: If a trust or institution receives any donation for a specific purpose, and the income is not used for that specific purpose, then the income will not be eligible for exemption under Section 11. For example, if a trust receives a donation for the construction of a hospital, and the income is used for any other purpose, then the income will not be exempt from tax.

f- Accumulation of income: Under Section 11(2), a trust or institution is allowed to accumulate income for a period of five years, if such accumulation is for the purpose of applying the income to charitable or religious purposes in India. However, if the income is not applied for such purposes within the specified period, then the accumulated income will not be exempt from tax.


Implications for taxpayers

For taxpayers who are running charitable or religious trusts or institutions, section 11 has important implications. Firstly, it provides an exemption from income tax for income that is applied for charitable or religious purposes in India. This can result in significant tax savings for the trust or institution, which can be used to further its charitable or religious activities.

Secondly, the conditions for exemption under section 11 are strict and must be met in order to claim the exemption. The trust or institution must ensure that its activities are primarily charitable or religious in nature, and that its income is spent only for such activities. It must also maintain proper accounts and file its tax return in a timely manner. Failure to meet these conditions can result in the denial of exemption under section 11.

Thirdly, section 11 has important implications for donors who contribute to charitable or religious trusts or institutions. Donations made to such trusts or institutions are eligible for deduction under section 80G of the Income Tax Act. This means that donors can claim a deduction of up to 50% of the amount donated, subject to certain limits and conditions. Therefore, section 11 can provide an incentive for donors to contribute to charitable or religious causes.








Commenti


bottom of page